Speech systems reduce the need for keyboards
Connecting state and local government leaders
I have been testing and using sound recognition and speech recognition hardware and software since 1982.
| SPECIAL TO GCNI have been testing and using sound recognition and speech recognition hardware and software since 1982.The early systems worked by speech training, meaning that they did not work at all until I trained them. But because they could only recognize a few hundred words, they could be surprisingly accurate and useful in controlling my computing environment.I have recently used two low-end speaker-independent speech recognition programs, IBM Corp.'s ViaVoice Standard and a version of Lernout & Hauspie's Dragon NaturallySpeaking that is similar to NaturallySpeaking Essentials, but it came bundled with other systems and is slightly different from the retail product.Of the two, ViaVoice is less useful for severely disabled users because it relies on keyboard or mouse cursor control and screen navigation. Using those controls is an advantage for people who can use navigation hardware'it reduces the number of commands ViaVoice has to learn and typically is faster than using voice commands. But it limits what many disabled users can do.More advanced versions of ViaVoice now include many voice navigation capabilities.ViaVoice also includes text-to-speech conversion, which can be fine-tuned to create a relatively pleasant, or at least tolerable, electronic voice.Dragon NaturallySpeaking can operate as a hands-off system and, in addition to taking dictation, can navigate documents, change fonts, edit, modify paragraph alignment and even create bulleted lists.Both low-end programs do well on discrete speech, when each word is spoken between distinct pauses, and both do fairly well right out of the box with continuous speech.More important, any speech recognition program will become easier to use and more accurate with time because the software can be trained.Both of these programs are speaker-independent. That is, they will work as initially installed for any English-language user who speaks clearly and consistently.Using either one of these programs puts a strain on a user, who must always speak in a controlled, even tone or jeopardize accuracy. I have tried, without notable success, to train older individuals to use these programs rather than have them try to learn touch typing. Each one found it difficult to rely on speech recognition. They usually were able to outperform it using hunt-and-peck, one-finger typing'especially because corrections to the speech recognition had to be typed in anyway and error rates were high.I have concluded that to use speech recognition successfully in its present form, a user must be already entirely comfortable with computers.That doesn't mean it isn't practical. A motivated person with severe motor control impairment could, with practice, easily achieve 20 words per minute or faster of text input. People who are really comfortable with speech recognition do even better, although slower computers will limit recognition speeds.I tested the low-end version of each product. There are more sophisticated editions with many valuable features, but they aren't noticeably more accurate when it comes to word recognition.Here is a sample of my first attempt to use ViaVoice after a few minutes of training:'Those the blind folded them to come to the the the party'Do you recognize the typist's standard test sentence: 'Now is the time for all good men to come to the aid of their party'?But using the training/correction mode, a few minutes later this was the result:'Know is the time for all good men to come to the aid of their party.'That's pretty close after only a few minutes of use, and it's a good indication that even the least expensive version of ViaVoice has real promise for motor-impaired users. And it is included with some IBM computers.XXXSPLITXXX-
BY JOHN MCCORMICK
Keyboard reliance
Accuracy is a concern
Keyboard reliance
Accuracy is a concern
| Vendor | Product | Platform | Notes | Price |
| IBM Corp. Armonk, N.Y. 914-499-1900 www.software.ibm.com | ViaVoice Standard | Win95 up | Basic speech recognition | $50 |
| ViaVoice Advanced | Win98 up | Includes large vocabulary, Web navigation, USB microphone | $90 | |
| ViaVoice Pro | Win95 up | Includes large vocabulary and powerful navigation tools | $189 | |
| ViaVoice Pro Elite | Win95 up | Uses desktop microphone instead of headset | $249 | |
| ViaVoice Mac Enhanced | Mac OS | Includes USB microphone | $141 | |
| Lernout & Hauspie Burlington, Mass. 781-203-5000 www.lhsl.com | Voice Express Standard | Win95 up | Basic speech recognition | $50 |
| Voice Express Advanced | Win95 up | Includes Word and WordPerfect command support | $80 | |
| Voice Express Mobile Professional | Win95 up | Includes Olympus digital voice recorder for dictation | $230 | |
| Voice Express Professional | Win95 up | Includes command control for Microsoft Office, including PowerPoint and Excel, along with speech synthesis | $149 | |
| Dragon NaturallySpeaking Essentials | Windows | Basic speech recognition includes e-mail and Web surfing support | $55 | |
| Dragon NaturallySpeaking Standard | Windows | Adds more sophisticated editing features | $100 | |
| Dragon NaturallySpeaking Preferred | Windows | Includes full-featured editing and navigation support for Word and WordPerfect | $169 | |
| Dragon NaturallySpeaking Preferred USB | Windows | Includes USB microphone | $210 | |
| Dragon NaturallySpeaking Professional Medical | Windows | Includes comprehensive medical vocabulary | $730 | |
| Dragon NaturallySpeaking Professional Legal | Windows | Includes comprehensive legal vocabulary | $690 | |
| Dragon NaturallySpeaking Professional Public Safety | Windows | Includes comprehensive public safety vocabulary, including profanity, acronyms | $570 |
NEXT STORY: You can check out a load of more information