Can Performance Pay Help States and Cities Hang onto the Best and Brightest?

Yutthana Gaetgeaw via Getty Images

After years in which compensation tied to performance was considered a “failed experiment,” workforce pressures are bringing it back to the table again.

It’s a simple truth: States, counties and cities are not going to be able to keep up with the private sector in terms of compensation. That means, in turn, that retention is always going to be a problem when their best and brightest employees are seduced by bigger paychecks that are available in corporate America.

One approach that holds some promise is performance pay, which is commonplace in companies. Though pay incentives for exceptional work are not a new idea in the public sector, the model is rare. The far more common alternative is basing an employee’s pay exclusively on longevity, “which is consistent, but it doesn’t change anyone’s behavior,” says David Kitchen, human resources manager for Lehi, Utah.

There has been growing interest in adopting performance pay. Cara Woodson Welch, executive director of the Public Sector HR Association says that anecdotally she has been “hearing more people talking about it recently.” She adds that she’s also seen a number of questions come up about the topic on the association’s online forum.

“Given the labor market and retention problems and recruitment issues, there has been more interest in performance pay,” confirms Juan Williams, commissioner of the Department of Human Resources in Tennessee, a pioneering state in the use of compensation that takes performance into account. “You can’t continue to operate the way you have and expect different outcomes.”

Performance pay is a revival of an idea that had been dismissed in the past “as a failed experiment,” says Leslie Scott, executive director of the National Association of State Personnel Executives. For one thing, evaluations upon which pay was based sometimes resulted in accusations of bias and favoritism, which left employees feeling bitter. Additionally, there have been concerns that performance pay creates competition among workers, which can damage a team-based environment.  

Unions often make this argument. As one leader of a teacher’s union told us, “Our teachers want to be in a pay system that thrives on collaboration and working with one another. They don’t want to be in a system that encourages competition. They want to be paid for their experience.”

Such objections have impeded the use of performance pay but, “I get the sense that better tools and technology for fairer performance evaluations increases the likelihood of [the approach’s] effectiveness,” says Scott.

Additionally, workforce shortages and high turnover rates have fostered an environment conducive to its use. “It’s good for retention because you can reward the people you want to retain—the high performers,” she says.

Louisiana is a state that already has a solid way to provide additional compensation to outstanding employees, by providing lump-sum payments for high performers. Employees can receive up to $2,500 in a year, or an amount no greater than 3% of their base pay. If that doesn’t seem like much of an incentive, consider this: The lowest level jobs in Louisiana state government start at $8 an hour or $16,640 a year. “So, an additional $500 can help that person a lot,” says Byron Decoteau, the state’s civil service director.

Louisiana’s performance evaluation system divides employees into three tiers: those who need improvement or are unsuccessful; people who are successful; and those who are exceptional. Only employees rated as exceptional are eligible for the lump-sum payment. These evaluations are based on their supervisor’s judgement of how they perform compared to goals set out for them. There’s a second level review, from someone higher up in the organization, in order to reduce subjectivity.

Another factor that can diminish the benefits of performance pay is a compulsion among some supervisors to rate nearly everyone at the top level to stay popular with staff. This trap has been avoided in Louisiana, as only 10% of employees can be rated as exceptional.

While Louisiana only uses performance pay in the form of one-time payments, Tennessee has long used the device more broadly to establish base pay levels. This effort began a little over a decade ago when the Tennessee Excellence, Accountability and Management Act was put into law, which placed a big emphasis on creating performance standards aligned with the governor’s priorities. Performance is based on the management formula SMART goals, which stands for specific, measurable, achievable, relevant and time sensitive.

This effort has evolved and in 2021-2022, the state began a four-year effort to improve its performance management plan, introducing, for example, evaluations that come not just from supervisors but also from peers and people who report to those being evaluated.

All of this is automated, and employees are evaluated in one of five categories: unacceptable, needs improvement, meets expectations, exceeds expectations and exceptional. Employees who meet expectations receive an increase in base salary; those who exceeded that get more and people rated as exceptional get the most. The percentages vary from year to year depending on how many people are in each of the categories and the amount of money available in the budget.

Tennessee has been able to avoid accusations of unfairness by ensuring that supervisors meet with direct reports four times a year. During these meeting, supervisors give employees the feedback they need to avoid feeling blindsided when it comes time to establish their next year’s pay level.

Says Williams, “There’ a commitment to it. We want our employees to perform at the highest level and performance-based pay has been a mechanism to accomplish that. We’ve been able to retain higher performers because we’re rewarding them. With this effort, we are more similar to the private sector firms with which we compete for jobs because we reward on performance and not just longevity.”

While performance pay can be used for almost any employee, it appears to be gaining traction particularly as a device to retain teachers, who are in very short supply in most cities and states.

Fueled in part by a desire to effectively utilize the state’s huge anticipated $1 billion surplus in the current fiscal year, the Oklahoma Senate has come out with a plan that would provide bonuses capped at 5% of pay and given to no more than the most outstanding 10% of teachers.

The specifics haven’t been worked out, according to Curtis Shelton, policy and research fellow for the Oklahoma Council of Public Affairs. But there’s a reasonable expectation, he says, that it would be based on evaluations that are currently in place for teachers—in part on peer and administrative evaluations, as well as several other non-performance-based criteria like participation in extra-curricular activities. And there is real support for the approach in the executive branch, as both the governor and the state’s elected superintendent of schools made rising student test scores a central part of their platforms in the last election.

Similarly, the North Carolina General Assembly is considering creating a pilot program in between five and 15 geographically and demographically diverse districts that could introduce a new compensation plan that would go beyond rewarding teachers solely for years of experience. Under consideration are a portfolio of evidence points including growth in student proficiency and evaluations from principals, assistant principals and peer teachers.

Says Van Dempsey, chair of the Professional Educator and Preparation Standards Commission, which provides oversight and recommendations about all aspects of education, “No single evaluation tool should be used and no teacher should ever be subjected to the judgement of one person.”

The pilot program, if passed, will give the state the opportunity to assess approaches to this work and the weighting of the various tools for evaluation. 

"We’re in a state of crisis in education in North Carolina now with great difficulties attracting and retaining teachers,” says Dempsey. “Compensation isn't going to solve these problems by itself, but we believe that this new structure has a great amount of potential."

Updated April 14, 2023: A previous version of this story suggested that a person making $16,640 a year in Louisiana could receive an additional $2,500 under the state's compensation program. That was unintentionally misleading as state employees can only receive additional compensation no greater than 3% of their base pay, which in the example given equals $499.20.

X
This website uses cookies to enhance user experience and to analyze performance and traffic on our website. We also share information about your use of our site with our social media, advertising and analytics partners. Learn More / Do Not Sell My Personal Information
Accept Cookies
X
Cookie Preferences Cookie List

Do Not Sell My Personal Information

When you visit our website, we store cookies on your browser to collect information. The information collected might relate to you, your preferences or your device, and is mostly used to make the site work as you expect it to and to provide a more personalized web experience. However, you can choose not to allow certain types of cookies, which may impact your experience of the site and the services we are able to offer. Click on the different category headings to find out more and change our default settings according to your preference. You cannot opt-out of our First Party Strictly Necessary Cookies as they are deployed in order to ensure the proper functioning of our website (such as prompting the cookie banner and remembering your settings, to log into your account, to redirect you when you log out, etc.). For more information about the First and Third Party Cookies used please follow this link.

Allow All Cookies

Manage Consent Preferences

Strictly Necessary Cookies - Always Active

We do not allow you to opt-out of our certain cookies, as they are necessary to ensure the proper functioning of our website (such as prompting our cookie banner and remembering your privacy choices) and/or to monitor site performance. These cookies are not used in a way that constitutes a “sale” of your data under the CCPA. You can set your browser to block or alert you about these cookies, but some parts of the site will not work as intended if you do so. You can usually find these settings in the Options or Preferences menu of your browser. Visit www.allaboutcookies.org to learn more.

Sale of Personal Data, Targeting & Social Media Cookies

Under the California Consumer Privacy Act, you have the right to opt-out of the sale of your personal information to third parties. These cookies collect information for analytics and to personalize your experience with targeted ads. You may exercise your right to opt out of the sale of personal information by using this toggle switch. If you opt out we will not be able to offer you personalised ads and will not hand over your personal information to any third parties. Additionally, you may contact our legal department for further clarification about your rights as a California consumer by using this Exercise My Rights link

If you have enabled privacy controls on your browser (such as a plugin), we have to take that as a valid request to opt-out. Therefore we would not be able to track your activity through the web. This may affect our ability to personalize ads according to your preferences.

Targeting cookies may be set through our site by our advertising partners. They may be used by those companies to build a profile of your interests and show you relevant adverts on other sites. They do not store directly personal information, but are based on uniquely identifying your browser and internet device. If you do not allow these cookies, you will experience less targeted advertising.

Social media cookies are set by a range of social media services that we have added to the site to enable you to share our content with your friends and networks. They are capable of tracking your browser across other sites and building up a profile of your interests. This may impact the content and messages you see on other websites you visit. If you do not allow these cookies you may not be able to use or see these sharing tools.

If you want to opt out of all of our lead reports and lists, please submit a privacy request at our Do Not Sell page.

Save Settings
Cookie Preferences Cookie List

Cookie List

A cookie is a small piece of data (text file) that a website – when visited by a user – asks your browser to store on your device in order to remember information about you, such as your language preference or login information. Those cookies are set by us and called first-party cookies. We also use third-party cookies – which are cookies from a domain different than the domain of the website you are visiting – for our advertising and marketing efforts. More specifically, we use cookies and other tracking technologies for the following purposes:

Strictly Necessary Cookies

We do not allow you to opt-out of our certain cookies, as they are necessary to ensure the proper functioning of our website (such as prompting our cookie banner and remembering your privacy choices) and/or to monitor site performance. These cookies are not used in a way that constitutes a “sale” of your data under the CCPA. You can set your browser to block or alert you about these cookies, but some parts of the site will not work as intended if you do so. You can usually find these settings in the Options or Preferences menu of your browser. Visit www.allaboutcookies.org to learn more.

Functional Cookies

We do not allow you to opt-out of our certain cookies, as they are necessary to ensure the proper functioning of our website (such as prompting our cookie banner and remembering your privacy choices) and/or to monitor site performance. These cookies are not used in a way that constitutes a “sale” of your data under the CCPA. You can set your browser to block or alert you about these cookies, but some parts of the site will not work as intended if you do so. You can usually find these settings in the Options or Preferences menu of your browser. Visit www.allaboutcookies.org to learn more.

Performance Cookies

We do not allow you to opt-out of our certain cookies, as they are necessary to ensure the proper functioning of our website (such as prompting our cookie banner and remembering your privacy choices) and/or to monitor site performance. These cookies are not used in a way that constitutes a “sale” of your data under the CCPA. You can set your browser to block or alert you about these cookies, but some parts of the site will not work as intended if you do so. You can usually find these settings in the Options or Preferences menu of your browser. Visit www.allaboutcookies.org to learn more.

Sale of Personal Data

We also use cookies to personalize your experience on our websites, including by determining the most relevant content and advertisements to show you, and to monitor site traffic and performance, so that we may improve our websites and your experience. You may opt out of our use of such cookies (and the associated “sale” of your Personal Information) by using this toggle switch. You will still see some advertising, regardless of your selection. Because we do not track you across different devices, browsers and GEMG properties, your selection will take effect only on this browser, this device and this website.

Social Media Cookies

We also use cookies to personalize your experience on our websites, including by determining the most relevant content and advertisements to show you, and to monitor site traffic and performance, so that we may improve our websites and your experience. You may opt out of our use of such cookies (and the associated “sale” of your Personal Information) by using this toggle switch. You will still see some advertising, regardless of your selection. Because we do not track you across different devices, browsers and GEMG properties, your selection will take effect only on this browser, this device and this website.

Targeting Cookies

We also use cookies to personalize your experience on our websites, including by determining the most relevant content and advertisements to show you, and to monitor site traffic and performance, so that we may improve our websites and your experience. You may opt out of our use of such cookies (and the associated “sale” of your Personal Information) by using this toggle switch. You will still see some advertising, regardless of your selection. Because we do not track you across different devices, browsers and GEMG properties, your selection will take effect only on this browser, this device and this website.